

Here's the question I kept coming back to: what can someone who argues for a living teach us about trust?
This week's guest is Mike Ehrenstein, founding partner of the Miami trial firm Ehrenstein Sager and a sixth-degree black belt in karate. Over 36 years in the courtroom, he has represented clients ranging from aerospace companies to the Republic of Angola, which he helped defend against more than a billion dollars in claims in a fight that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Few leaders have to earn trust as quickly as a trial lawyer. Mike has minutes during jury selection to win over a room of strangers, and as he put it, that trust "has to last for the entirety of a trial." One of his biggest lessons came from a closing argument a mentor scripted for him. He delivered it as told, and it fell flat because it wasn't him.
Authenticity also means owning the weak spots. "In every case that goes to trial, there's always some bad fact," Mike said. He names it up front and explains why his client should still win, because glossing over it costs him the jury's trust.
Research backs him up. In a classic set of mock-trial experiments published in Law and Human Behavior, attorneys who revealed damaging information before the other side could raise it significantly reduced its impact. The reason: disclosure made the side that revealed it more credible. Psychologists call this "stealing thunder."
Newer work extends the finding beyond the courtroom. A 2025 study in Social Influence found that when doctors and politicians who disclosed a mistake also explained why they were coming forward, people rated them as more trustworthy and credible, even when no corrective action was offered.
We also talked about:
Why trust with a jury is a two-way street,
Staying calm when a case takes a bad turn mid-trial,
Inviting opposing counsel to dinner before the fight begins,
Building trust inside a fully virtual firm, and
Delivering hard news to a client who trusts you.
These lessons are not reserved for the courtroom. Sooner or later, every leader has a bad fact to share.
Listen or watch now on Win Via Trust or your favorite podcast apps including:YouTube, Apple, and Spotify.
THE BOTTOM LINE
Trust is often decided by how we handle the facts that hurt us. Mike earns a jury's trust by naming his case's weak spots before anyone else can, and the research shows why it works: disclosure reads as credibility. Whether your audience is a jury, a board, or your own team, the people you lead are watching for the same thing.
They need to see me, the authentic me, with all the warts. – Mike Ehrenstein
WINNING MOVES
Steal your own thunder. When there's bad news, share it first, and explain why you're raising it. Letting others discover it costs far more trust than saying it yourself.
Listen before you fix. Mike's practical step for this week: sit down with a team member, ask what is making their work harder, and commit to one action that shows you heard them.
Build the relationship before the conflict. Like Mike's dinners with opposing counsel, invest time with colleagues, partners, and even rivals before you need a favor. Trust built in calm moments holds up under pressure.
Please view the interview on the Win Via Trust leadership podcast for great insights and advice.
If you want to dig deeper into the trust side of leadership, please read Win Via Trust or subscribe below for future Trust Lens newsletters.
